‘Am I not a person?’ Florida Supreme Court ponders police anonymity under Marsy’s Law
Florida Supreme Court Justice John Curiel listens to arguments on Wednesday, Dec. 7, 2022 in a case concerning Marsy’s Law.
The Florida Supreme Court grilled attorneys on both sides of a dispute between the city of Tallahassee and the police union on whether the identities of officers who kill suspects can be kept secret under Marsy’s Law, a constitutional amendment designed to protect victims of crime.
The case arose from two separate incidents in 2020 in which Tallahassee Police Department officers shot and killed armed suspects who were threatening them. The officers’ were later cleared by a grand jury, and both sides acknowledged that their conduct was not an issue.
Both officers, known to the public only as John Doe 1 and 2, sought protection after the shootings under Marsy’s Law, which Florida voters approved in 2018. The law, marketed to voters as a way to ensure crime victims were put on an even playing field as defendants in court, includes pro...